Best Practices for End-of-Year Performance Reviews
As the end of the year approaches, businesses are reviewing their balance sheets, reflecting on their growth, identifying problem areas, and developing a game plan for 2026. Among the tasks business owners should prioritize completing at the end of the year, performance reviews should be listed at the top. Employees are the lifeblood of a company; checking in with them and monitoring their progress with a performance review is vital to retaining top talent, fostering loyalty, and improving your bottom line.
End-of-year performance reviews are an important touchpoint for employers and employees. It’s important to understand how this process benefits your company and the best practices for conducting it. Continue reading to learn more about the benefits of end-of-year performance reviews and how to run them effectively.
Introducing Performance Reviews
An end-of-year employee performance review is an evaluation of an employee’s performance throughout the year. While the metrics for a successful year depend on the individual, the purpose of these reviews is to help the employee and employer discuss topics ranging from job performance, training, areas for improvement, and career development. These reviews are also great times for employees to discuss compensation, potential promotions or raises, and to strategize for the upcoming year.
Benefits of an end-of-year performance review
Performance reviews provide a variety of benefits to the entire company. They can:
- Build a workplace culture that prioritizes employee growth
- Clarify employee expectations and objectives
- Foster greater communication across management levels
- Improve employee engagement and productivity
- Provide personalized guidance on career development
- Clarify job expectations
- Improve morale
Best Practices for Conducting Performance Reviews
Prepare thoroughly
To effectively conduct a performance review, preparation is essential. Gather data from the past year; this data can include peer feedback, the employee’s previous goals, past performance reviews, and self-evaluations. Then, based on that data, develop important talking points for the meeting and make notes on the most important points to discuss. It’s also key to schedule time at the end of the meeting for employee questions and concerns.
Prioritize open communication
During the review, encourage your employees to share their perspectives and the challenges they’ve faced this year. Hearing their point of view can strengthen your relationship and allow you to gain a stronger understanding of their strengths, weaknesses, and future goals.
Set goals
One of the main objectives of conducting end-of-year performance reviews is to track an employee’s professional progress from the beginning to the end of the year. But an equally important objective of these reviews is to plan and set employee goals for the next year. Setting KPIs and goals for the following year acts as a benchmark for progress and professional development.
While professional goals differ from employee to employee, they should be specific, actionable, and measurable. By working with your employees on their goals, you can set a precedent for what they should focus on during the next year and help them build a plan for how they are going to achieve them.
Maintain regular check-ins
End-of-year performance reviews are a common process throughout businesses, but you shouldn’t wait until the end of the year to check in with your workforce. By scheduling consistent reviews and check-ins, you foster a culture focused on open communication, employee development, and trust. Employees are also more likely to reach their goals by checking in with their employers and adjusting their benchmarks or KPIs as they see fit.
Employee Management Assistance
Performance reviews are about growth, communication, and organizational alignment. When approached thoughtfully, they strengthen relationships, enhance productivity, and create a thriving workplace culture. Employees are the cornerstone of a strong and successful company, and by checking in with them, your business is one step closer to overall development and growth.
While you may not be an expert in performance reviews, Group Management Services (GMS) can help. With our knowledgeable Human Resources (HR) team, we consult business owners on best practices for employee growth and management initiatives. We can assist with writing employee handbooks, recruitment, employee training, and more. From performance reviews and HR audits to unemployment, GMS can help your business and employees thrive. Learn more about our HR services here!