Skip to Content

The Speed Vs. Accuracy Dilemma: Why Employers Must Reevaluate Their Priorities In Their Background Screening Process

The Speed Vs. Accuracy Dilemma: Why Employers Must Reevaluate Their Priorities In Their Background Screening Process

In today’s hyper-competitive job market, employers are racing to secure the best talent swiftly. As a result, the need for speed in every aspect of the hiring process has become more pronounced, including background screening. However, this relentless pursuit of speed may inadvertently overshadow the vital aspect of accuracy. Let’s explore the challenges and consequences of prioritizing speed over accuracy when choosing a background-screening provider and why striking the right balance is crucial for the long-term success of any organization.

The Need For Speed: A Pressing Imperative

In a rapidly evolving business landscape, time is of the essence. Employers face mounting pressure to fill positions, stay ahead of competitors, and keep pace with changing market demands. Consequently, background-screening providers are increasingly marketed based on the promise of rapid turnaround times, promising quick results that can expedite the hiring process.

The Hidden Dangers Of Prioritizing Speed Over Accuracy 

  1. Incomplete information: Opting for a background-screening provider solely based on speed may lead to incomplete information about potential candidates. Crucial details might be overlooked, leaving employers exposed to unforeseen risks.
  2. Legal and reputational risks: Relying on quick background checks can increase the likelihood of overlooking red flags in a candidate’s history, such as criminal records or false credentials. This leaves companies vulnerable to legal liabilities and damages their reputation.
  3. High employee turnover: By prioritizing speed over accuracy, employers might hire candidates who are not a good fit for the role or the company culture. This can lead to high employee turnover rates, hampering organizational growth and productivity.

The Quest For Balance: Redefining Priorities 

  1. Reevaluating criteria: Employers should reassess their screening criteria and identify critical information for decision-making. This way, they can streamline the screening process while ensuring that essential details are not missed.
  2. Partnering with reliable providers: Instead of blindly opting for the fastest provider, employers should prioritize working with reputable screening agencies with a track record of accuracy. A trusted partner will deliver timely results without compromising quality.
  3. Leveraging technology: Embrace technology-driven solutions that combine speed and accuracy. Automated systems can expedite the process without sacrificing the thoroughness of the investigation.
  4. Conducting comprehensive interviews: Supplement background checks with in-depth interviews to gain insights into candidates’ personalities, values, and work ethics. This holistic approach ensures a more thorough evaluation of potential hires.

Embracing The Long-Term Vision

While the desire for speedy results is understandable, employers must recognize that hasty decisions may have far-reaching consequences. Investing time and effort in choosing the right background-screening provider can lead to better hiring choices, improved retention rates, and a stronger organizational culture.

A PEO May Be The Solution

As employers navigate the ever-changing landscape of talent acquisition, it’s essential to strike the right balance between speed and accuracy in background screenings. While quick results may seem attractive in the short term, the long-term benefits of thorough and accurate background checks cannot be underestimated.

In the quest for accurate background checks that relieve business owners of their responsibility, a professional employer organization (PEO) like GMS stands as a valuable partner. By partnering with GMS, businesses can confidently delegate the responsibility of conducting meticulous background screenings to experts who specialize in the field. A PEO’s wealth of experience, access to advanced screening technology, and compliance with evolving regulations ensure that the hiring process remains swift and precise.

Amber Mora, GMS’ HR Account Manager, explains, “When partnering with GMS, our clients save a significant amount of time because all they have to do is send over the candidate information, and our recruiters handle the rest. They securely input the information into the software we use for background checks called CrimCheck. The completed results are then sent back to the client. Should the client decide not to move forward with a candidate, we can submit the adverse action process on their behalf so they don’t have to worry about it. Ultimately, we make it easy for our clients to have background checks completed.”

Embracing a PEO empowers business owners to focus on their core objectives, securing the knowledge that reliable professionals bolster their workforce. In the dynamic landscape of modern business, GMS’ support can be the key to building a thriving and ethically responsible organization. Get a quote from us today!



Return to Blog